From TC: I really enjoyed Act of Oblivion and rate it 10/10. I thought it might be a bit boring and heavy but found it well written, good pace and I could engage with the characters. 14/10/2025
From TC: I really enjoyed Act of Oblivion and rate it 10/10. I thought it might be a bit boring and heavy but found it well written, good pace and I could engage with the characters. 14/10/2025
The Elephanta Suite: I should have read a little about it before I got stuck in as I expected more overt linking of the three sections as I was reading it. I only realised afterwards, on reflection, that it was indeed linked by different experiences of Americans there. Duh!
I found it quite thought provoking, not least after the last of the stories had a quite unexpected (for me)
ending.
The author is one I've heard of but never read before. I liked his style, even though I might have steered
clear of the book if details of the content would have been on the blurb.
My rating- a 6. FW
Now, the Paul Theroux book - started off ok and well written just lost interest with all the sordid affairs
and exploitation of young indigenous girls - read about 150 pages and scanned the rest, didn't think it
was worth my time! Barely 5/10 Agreed with Dwight when he asks on P167 -"How had he been
corrupted so quickly...prey"!! and P244 -top "most things that people....with it." Did the 3 main
characters link up?
(must have missed that bit!) SC
But I have read the book. Took it to Amsterdam & Bruges and got strangely hooked on it on
Eurostar 2 weeks ago and was pleased to have a book that was well crafted and I looked forward
to reading it - actually stopped reading occasionally to stare out of the window and
ponder on how I would have reacted if something in the plot had happened to me.
HOWEVER... writing this 2 weeks on I can't remember anything about what I read! It was
totally forgettable. I didn't 'get inside' any of the characters' heads in any of the stories.
The book didn't linger in my brain afterwards. I read it then moved on with my life.
SO... it's a 5 for me. HB
And my review from 2013:
Not finished. It was a depressing book made up of three stories about different Elephanta suites.
In all stories Americans come to India. the first, after Mr. & Mrs each have a brief affair with an
Indian they are effectively thrown out and possibly killed.
In the second a business man in India becomes enthralled with a young girl, then his business partner
leads him into eastern mysticism, and Dwight gives up all to pursue it, handling over
the American business to Shah, who is eager to grab it. The third was about a young girl in an
Ashram, who tries to leave. Marks - 1
His 4th Autobiography. His earliest years remembered. What he remembers himself from those times, with the turbulent state of his mothers household, and also added in things about British and world history that make it more interesting, as well as what other people were doing at that time - 1944-1952.
It was difficult to get started because it was not exactly linear, but more interesting finding out about what was happening in the world later in the book, because this was my time.
It seems that quite a few people skimmed through the middle of the book and just read the beginning and end. It was the kind of book that you could pick up and put down, and just read bits.
There was lots of discussion about his early life, and the things that he thought he saw. His life was reflecting the decline of England?
The book was well written. The overriding comment was that people were glad to have read it, but didn't enjoy it.
MArks - 4-6-6-7-6-6-8-5-5 = 53/9 - about 6.
We had a blank month on our library reading list, so we chose this book. It's different, it's suspend belief funny, and enjoyable.
Retired detective Steve Father in law of Amy, a close protection officer, whose blood has been found at three murders of customers of her company, Lots of possible villains who all have a finger in it somewhere, and people who are nefarious behind their innocuous cover stories. Amy is protecting a very rich female author, who when asked if she has something says 'yes, I think I've got one somewhere', or 'Doesn't everyone have a private jet?' And she is horny as hell.
My Mark 8 - I would read another of his stories along this line.
9,9,8,8,7,5,4,2.5 Avg: 6.5
This is the story of his wife Joan's death from cancer, interspersed with reminiscences. It is hard to give any feelings about it. You can't believe that it was written as a money making thing. It is very personal, so why publish it aside from a few copies for the family.
Nobody thought very much of it, too many references to celebs that he knew and we had never heard of.
Agreed mark of 3.
I have enjoyed this book. It is very emotional at the end when a new family of the same sort of mindset is looking at his house. I loved his hate of the white shirts bureaucrats and the way that he treated them and the way that he looked after his neighbours, if somewhat unwillingly. Mark - 9 from me.
PH: A man called Ove is one of my favourite books. A gentle, easy read, original story line and well written, with great bits of humour too. As a cat lover, I loved the cameo roles played by the cat. Not exactly a literary classic, but a very nice book – hence a 9 out of 10 from me.
SIMPSON DAYS FROM A DIFFERENT WORLD 29/07/2025 THEROUX ELEPHANTA SUITE 26/08/2025 HARRIS ACT OF OBLIVION 23/09/2025 TYLER NOAHS COMPASS 28/10/2025 MACINNES IN ASCENSION 15/11/2025 FALLON JUST GOT REAL 16/12/2025 BROAD ABROAD IN JAPAN 27/01/2026 DENCH SHAKESPEARE: THE MAN WHO PAYS THE RENT 24/02/2026 BARRY OLD GOD'S TIME 24/03/2026 CRAIG THREE GRACES 28/04/2026 CATTON BIRNAM WOOD 26/05/2026 MCCALL SMITH PAVILION IN THE CLOUDS 23/06/2026 |